[link]It seems that our idiotic neo-con wannabe government (robo Harpo) is once again trying to ram some very restrictive inbred legislation down Canadian throats. If this updated Copyright Act amendment were to pass:
- copying a file from a CD you purchased to your iPod would be illegal
- downloading a song from a P2P network would get you a $500 fine, per song!
(even if you owned the CD!)
- copying a recorded or time-shifted program from your Tivo or PVR would be illegal
- unlocking a locked cell phone (to use on another carrier) would be illegal
- owning unlocking software would get you jail time!
- using deCSS of similar decrypting program just to play your legit DVD on Linux,
that would be illegal!
- hacking your DVD player (or PC internal DVD drive) to handle multi region play - illegal!
- using your $10 Chinese DVD player (without proper MPEG licenses) would be illegal!
- using any of your music as background for your YouTube posted video -illegal!
(yes, there is a doctrine of "fair use" , but not since the RIAA treats all music listeners
as criminals...)
Basically, it's an open invitation for the likes of the American RIAA and MPAA to sue Canadians cross-border and run roughshod over our privary, rights, and music.
We've been preached that performance works such as music and movies are are actually PROPERTY, like cars, and thus require protection from stealing, just like cars.
At least when you buy a car, you own it. Ford can't come knocking on your door and say they want it back or that they want to make sure you don't let anyone else drive it!
The don't have that right; you have a receipt. But MUSIC, oh, that's a different animal, they want us to believe (after taking our money). They want to rent it to us.
Look at the way iTunes works now. You really don't own the music you "buy". You are only renting it. In fact if Apple decided to nuke your tunes, they'd be all gone. They are all tied to your account, and not to local copies you have on your PC. If your account were to be disabled, stolen, hijacked or compromised, all your music could be rendered unplayable in an electronic microsecond. The upside is that if your PC was stolen, you could retrieve all your rented music onto your new computer, but let's make it clear, that the music is NOT your property, it's Apple's, since they control it. They can give it back to you, if you are nice.
Yes, I know stealing it stealing, but it's not exactly the same, borrowing bits as stealing a diamond ring (or a bag of chips) from a store. For example, I have something like 30+ gigs of mp3 music, for which I have only about 300 CDs I've purchased. Am I a thief? Maybe I've listened to a song once, twice, or maybe never. I don't share those songs, I don't deprive the artists from revenue. If I don't play music I really like more than once, I'd likely never buy it either! The reality of music CD packaging is that you get one or 2 good tracks and rest is pure tripe. Worse, the way most music is viewed as now (by the seller/producer) is not that you OWN it. You really are only having a very limited right to listen to it. For now, you can legally make a copy to listen to in your car, but if this bill passed you won't be. Next time you get pulled over for speeding, the cop may demand a full copy of your iPod and ding you $500 for every song you have on there! I don't put it past the American psycho-cop mentality to cross the border, with RIAA sponsored Music-Police harassing people at every street corner. Welcome to your new police state, people!
So at 30 gigs of music ( though it might be 50 gigs by now), say 10,000 songs, at $500 dollar fine is $5 million dollars! However if I were to buy each song on iTunes for 99 cents, I'd spend only $9900 ! So which is it, what is a song really worth!?
You might say to me, just go out and buy the music! I do, if I can. Most what I like
to listen to is no longer available, only available in used shops, on vinyl or cassette, so there is little recourse. For music I like, music I listen to regularly, I will spend money, so long as the music company doesn't try to hijack and infest my computer (like the infamous Sony rootkit fiasco). But those bastards won't get my money if they bury the music so deep in protection schemes, rules and regulations and excessive restrictions on how and where I can enjoy that music. So, I will take my chances. In the meantime, I suggest you try to support band ands music companies that maximize profits for the actual performers and not the parasitic record labels, advertizers and assorted pimps.
Do you think you won't get caught? Think again! Almost all filthy ISPs are now using sleazy application filtering - bandwidth throttling, to degrade P2P, torrent etc services. So they know exactly who, when and what (down to the filename) you download and share. The onus would then not be on the RIAA to determine this, they'd simply have the legal right to subpoena (on mass) records on all copyright infringers and send them the bills, as they have been doing in the the United States of Amerca (land of the free!).
Pay the bill or they take you to court - criminal court!
Recently, in my town, a little local company went up against the MPAA. They make a dandy entertainment system that sucks all your DVDs onto a hard drive, so you can play them easily on your TV, or PC in any room in the house! Great! Well, not according to the MPAA. The DVD licensing association (thanks to the MPAA) insists that the PHYSICAL DVD be inserted in a jukebox and verified to be proper and real, before allowing it to be played! The MPAA lost the case, and freedom triumphed, but under this new law, that small win will be erased: it will be illegal to copy any DVD material at all! It doesn't matter if you can prove you bought that copy of Nemo, even if it's sitting right on top of the TV, in the eyes of the MPAA (and probably soon the Canadian government) you are a pirate and criminal!
So what will be the outcome of this? Simple. As in all cat and mouse games, the mouse simply gets smarter, until eventually the cats catches it, and then the cycle starts again.
I expect that "private sharing software" will come out - allowing you to share your music collection with only your most trusted friends. All communications will be encrypted. Alternate underground firmware loads for popular MP3 players will come out that ignore Apple, Microsoft, Sony DRM and scramble the music, so if caught, there will be no evidence to be used against you.
Thank you, Industry Minister Jim Prentice, for dumping this steaming dung pile of a bill, just before you and your cronies take off for the summer, hoping it will quietly pass. Be sure to enjoy your American entertainment lobbyist kickbacks, and be assured that if your measly minority government falls because of this bill, it will be because of YOU!
The revolution begins with you people! Time to sharpen the pitchforks! It's time to bring this nonsense to an end! Stupid governments, stupid wars, stupid laws.
Bring them all down!
Instead of spending trillions on killing innocent civilians, let's spend the money instead on healthcare, education, scientific research and paying the police to do what they need to do - apprehend the REAL criminals: murderers, drug dealers, rapists, child molesters and politicians.